1. DEBT SOLUTIONS

Is a Balance Transfer Card Harder to Get Right Now?

Is a Balance Transfer Card Harder to Get Right Now?
BY Sara Korn
Jul 17, 2020
 - Updated 
Sep 18, 2024
Key Takeaways:
  • During a recession, it can be harder to get a balance transfer card.
  • Debt consolidation loans can be an alternative to balance transfers.
  • If your debt is truly serious, consider debt relief for a fresh start.

In April and May, credit card lenders drastically reduced the number of balance transfer offers they sent out, down by about 77% compared to the same time last year, according to a report by Mintel Comperemedia.

Due to loss of income from the coronavirus financial crisis, consumers may be relying more on credit cards. But now, lenders appear increasingly concerned about extending credit to people they believe may not be able to pay what they owe. For consumers, this means it could be harder to get a balance transfer card now than it was just a few months ago.

If you’ve been considering using a balance transfer to help you manage your debt, here’s what you need to know.

How does a balance transfer card work?

In general, balance transfer credit cards can be a useful tool to help manage debt. The cards offer a low or 0% interest rate for a limited amount of time (called a promotional period), which can help save on interest charges if you pay down the balance you transfer over during the promotional period. There’s typically a balance transfer fee of around 3%-5% of the amount you transfer.

Can I qualify for a balance transfer card even during the recession?

While the usual balance transfer terms are still available from most credit card companies, lenders are being more selective about who they give offers to. Normally, you’d need a good credit score (around 700+) and sufficient income relative to the amount of debt to qualify. However, every lender sets their own qualification criteria, and it can change as credit card companies re-evaluate the risk of these types of loans.

The important questions to ask yourself are:

  1. Is a balance transfer the best strategy for managing my debt?

  2. What other alternatives are there, and how do they compare?

If you’re going through a short-term hardship due to COVID-19, but are confident you can get back on track paying down debt once your income situation stabilizes, one alternative to a balance transfer would be to ask your lenders for forbearance.

If you were already struggling with heavy debt before the current recession, then a balance transfer may or may not help you. In fact, it could even make your debt situation worse.

Balance transfers make the most sense if you can pay all or most of the debt before the promotional period ends and if you’re transferring a relatively small amount of debt. It’s also important to calculate how much you’d save in interest charges compared to your current card and make sure it’s more than what the balance transfer fee on the new card would be.

Alternatives for managing personal debt

If a balance transfer doesn’t make sense in your situation, or you’re not able to qualify for one in the current environment, the good news is that you have other options, including:

Asking your credit card company for a forbearance could be the easiest way to get immediate relief from payments and collection calls, but it could also prolong your debt if interest continues to build up while you’re not making payments. A consolidation loan, credit counseling, and debt settlement all require that you have income so you can pay down your debt.

If you don’t have a job at the moment, ask your lenders for a forbearance. Once you’re employed again, consider the other options on the list. If your debt is so overwhelming that you can’t manage the payments even with an income, then bankruptcy may be your best option.

Wondering how to best manage your debt right now?

The good news is, there are several options available to help you manage your personal debt. To figure out what makes the most sense in your particular situation, it can help to talk to a Certified Debt Consultant who is trained and certified by the IAPDA to help consumers understand their debt resolution options. To get a free consultation with one of our Certified Debt Consultants, get started here.

Learn More:

Debt relief by the numbers

We looked at a sample of data from Freedom Debt Relief of people seeking debt relief during August 2024. This data reveals the diversity of individuals seeking help and provides insights into some of their key characteristics.

Credit utilization and debt relief

How are people using their credit before seeking help? Credit utilization measures how much of a credit line is being used. For example, if you have a credit line of $10,000 and your balance is $3,000, that is a credit utilization of 30%. High credit utilization often signals financial stress. We have looked at people who are seeking debt relief and their credit utilization. (Low credit utilization is 30% or less, medium is between 31% and 50%, high is between 51% and 75%, very high is between 76% to 100%, and over-utilized over 100%). In August 2024, people seeking debt relief had an average of 88% credit utilization.

Here are some interesting numbers:

Credit utilization bucketPercent of debt relief seekers
Over utilized88%
Very high5%
High3%
Medium1%
Low3%

The statistics refer to people who had a credit card balance greater than $0.

You don't have to have high credit utilization to look for a debt relief solution. There are a number of solutions for people, whether they have maxed out their credit cards or still have a significant part available.

Student loan debt  – average debt by selected states.

According to the 2023 Federal Reserve Survey of Consumer Finances (SCF) the average student debt for those with a balance was $46,980. The percentage of families with student debt was 22%. (Note: It used 2022 data).

Student loan debt among those seeking debt relief is prevalent. In August 2024, 24% of the debt relief seekers had student debt. The average student debt balance (for those with student debt) was 50087.

Here is a quick look at the top five states by average student debt balance.

StatePercent with student loansAverage Balance for those with student loansAverage monthly payment
Washington DC29$85,809$208
Mississipi29$58,265$181
Georgia31$56,074$145
New Jersey29$54,691$197
Maryland26$54,410$124

The statistics are based on all debt relief seekers with a student loan balance over $0.

Student debt is an important part of many households' financial picture. When you examine your finances, consider your total debt and your monthly payments.

Support for a Brighter Future

No matter your age, FICO score, or debt level, seeking debt relief can provide the support you need. Take control of your financial future by taking the first step today.

Show source